Untersuchungen der Kriegsverbrechen in Butscha

09. April 2022

The Euro­pean Com­mis­si­on “encou­ra­ges” mem­ber sta­tes that have ope­ned inves­ti­ga­ti­ons into pos­si­ble war cri­mes in Ukrai­ne to join the joint inves­ti­ga­ti­on team coor­di­na­ted by the judi­cial coope­ra­ti­on agen­cy Euro­just, a spo­kes­per­son said on Wed­nes­day. of the Euro­pean executive.

Eight coun­tries (Fran­ce, Czech Repu­blic, Ger­ma­ny, Esto­nia, Lat­via, Slo­va­kia, Swe­den, Spain) have ope­ned natio­nal surveys.

src: click

Der Typ der die Coor­di­na­ti­on der unter­schied­li­chen natio­na­len Unter­su­chungs­teams unter dem Schirm des EU joint inves­ti­ga­ti­on teams for­dert ist Didier Reyn­ders.

Didier Reyn­ders ist auch für die Free­ze and Sei­ze Task for­ce zustän­dig, die inner­halb der EU Olig­ar­chen­ver­mö­gen ein­friert. *autsch*

Didier Reyn­ders hält auch kon­struk­ti­ve Mee­tings mit dem Zelen­skyy cabi­net, wel­che Hil­fe man zur Samm­lung und Spei­che­rung von Beweis­ma­te­ri­al anbie­ten kön­ne. Die Mee­tings waren dem was ich den Twit­ter Mit­tei­lun­gen ent­neh­men kann, so kon­struk­tiv, das man sich vor allem auf wei­te­re Mee­tings geei­nigt hat.

Ein von Pro­fil befrag­ter Men­schen­rechts­ex­per­te fin­det das mög­li­cher­wei­se leicht pro­ble­ma­tisch, da Putin im Fal­le von Unter­su­chun­gen die nicht von den UN gelei­tet wur­den deren Unab­hän­gig­keit in Fra­ge stel­len könnte.

Wen­den wir uns der UN zu.

Michel­le Bache­let, the United Nati­ons High Com­mis­sio­ner for Human Rights said that she was hor­ri­fied by the­se images. In a state­ment, Ms Bache­let said that the­se and other reports from Ukrai­ne “rai­se serious and dis­tur­bing ques­ti­ons about pos­si­ble war cri­mes as well as gra­ve breaches of inter­na­tio­nal huma­ni­ta­ri­an law and serious vio­la­ti­ons of inter­na­tio­nal human rights law.”

She said all mea­su­res should be taken to pre­ser­ve evidence.

It is vital that all efforts are made to ensu­re the­re are inde­pen­dent and effec­ti­ve inves­ti­ga­ti­ons into what hap­pen­ed in Bucha to ensu­re truth, jus­ti­ce and accoun­ta­bi­li­ty, as well as repa­ra­ti­ons and reme­dy for vic­tims and their families.”

src: click

Und wie läuft das so ab? Pod­cast to the res­cue: click

OHCHR office: “Work needs to be done to estab­lish if a spe­ci­fic inci­dence was a warcrime. But what is clear is that under inter­na­tio­nal law, the deli­be­ra­te kil­ling of civi­li­ans is a war crime.”

Inter­view­er: “So, you have a human rights team in Ukrai­ne in Kiyv, I under­stand, in the capi­tal, what are their plans to get to Bucha, to see for them­sel­ves, and to start the real foren­sic pro­cess, thats invol­ved in say­ing, whe­ther the­re has been a war crime.”

OHCHR office: “Inde­ed we have a pre­sence in Ukrai­ne, that has in fact been the­re sin­ce 2014, based in the capi­tal Kyiv, but also in other loca­ti­ons in the coun­try. As of now, the majo­ri­ty of the team are based in the far west of the coun­try in a place cal­led Usch­ho­rod. They have a team of som 37 human rights offi­cers based the­re. Now, what col­le­gues are aiming to do is to get to loca­ti­ons liek Bucha, to see for them­sel­ves, what may have hap­pen­ed, and also import­ant­ly and also important an cru­cial­ly, to talk to vic­tims and talk to wit­nes­ses, this is cru­cial human rights work, to get first hand infor­ma­ti­on, to help estab­lish what may have hap­pen­ed. Its pain­sta­king work of cour­se, and its work, that needs to be con­duc­ted very care­ful­ly, becau­se the car­di­nal princip­le of human rights work is to do no harm, is to avoid ret­rau­ma­ti­zing people […]”

Also gute Nach­rich­ten vom OHCHR sie wer­den Mit­glie­der ihres lan­ge bestehen­den Ukrai­ne Office in das Gebiet schicken.

Was machen die Ukrai­ner der­wei­len eigent­lich so?

Blin­ken after mee­ting with Nato for­eign ministers:

Fourth, the United Sta­te con­ti­nues to work metho­di­cal­ly to collect, to pre­ser­ve, to ana­ly­ze evi­dence of atro­ci­ties and to make this infor­ma­ti­on avail­ab­le to the appro­pria­te bodies. We’re sup­por­ting a mul­ti­na­tio­nal team of experts that’s assis­ting a war cri­mes unit set up by Ukraine’s pro­se­cu­tor gene­ral, with a view toward even­tual­ly pur­suing cri­mi­nal accountability.

src: click

Ah, seht gut, die US bie­ten einem inter­na­tio­na­len Team das vom ukrai­ni­schen Gene­ral­staats­an­walt auf­ge­baut wird ihre volls­te Unter­stüt­zung und Zusam­men­ar­beit an.

Das war die Quel­le aus der die höchs­te bis­her gemel­de­te Opfer­zahl in Butscha stammt.
That’s just one per­son Rus­si­an sol­di­ers kil­led in Bucha. Accord­ing to Ukraine’s pro­se­cu­tor gene­ral, they’ve alrea­dy found 410 bodies of dead civi­li­ans in that one town alone.

The­se efforts will also ensu­re that Rus­sia can­not escape the ver­dict of history.

Ah, gut - der ICC wird dafür sor­gen, dass Gerech­tig­keit her­ge­stellt wird!

Zelen­skyy:

We are dealing with inva­ders who have not­hing human left. To jus­ti­fy their own kil­lings, they take the mur­de­red peop­le sim­ply as sce­ne­ry, as pro­pa­gan­da props. And this is a sepa­ra­te war crime, for which each of the pro­pa­gan­dists will be held accountable.

More and more coun­tries around the world sup­port the need for a full and trans­pa­rent inves­ti­ga­ti­on of all war cri­mes of the Rus­si­an occu­p­iers in Ukrai­ne. Every mur­der case will be sol­ved. Each of the tor­tu­rers will be found. All tho­se who com­mit­ted rape or loo­ting will be iden­ti­fied. Respon­si­bi­li­ty is inevitable.

src: click

With that said, doubts regar­ding the ICC’s juris­dic­tion on this mat­ter have been omni­pre­sent, con­si­de­ring that neit­her Ukrai­ne nor Rus­sia is a sta­te par­ty to the Rome statute.

src: click

Oh, das macht ja aber nichts, weil man kann ja auf Ansin­nen Est­lands und 38 wei­te­rer Staa­ten trotz­dem eine Unter­su­chung einleiten!
src: click
(Die Ent­schei­dung fiel am 28. Febru­ar, also vor dem Bekannt­wer­den des Mas­sa­kers in Butsca.)

Ah, das ist gut, da wer­den sich sicher auch ande­re Unrechts­re­gime vor dem ICC zu ver­ant­wor­ten haben! Kei­ne Straf­frei­heit für Kriegsverbrecher!

Oh -

Naja, jetzt bin ich aber ein wenig abge­schweift, zurück zu den Foren­si­kern in Butscha:

Die Ukrai­ni­schen Ermitt­ler haben begon­nen die Mas­sen­grä­ber zu exhu­mie­ren: click - unter der Zustän­dig­keit des ukrai­ni­schen Generalstaatsanwalts.

[Rus­lan] Krav­chen­ko [Rus­lan Krav­chen­ko from the prosecutor’s office] said the foren­sic inves­ti­ga­tors would work to build up a pic­tu­re of what hap­pen­ed to tho­se buried in the gra­ve, adding the inves­ti­ga­ti­on into the deaths was “unpre­ce­den­ted” in scale.

Eini­ge Kör­per wur­den für foren­si­sche Unter­su­chun­gen am 4. April, von den Ukrai­ni­schen Behör­den, von ihren Fund­or­ten weg­be­wegt. src: click

Ers­ter Augenzeuge:
sie­he click (nach edit2 suchen)

Zwei­ter Augenzeuge:

On March 4, Rus­si­an for­ces in Bucha, about 30 kilo­me­ters nor­thwest of Kyiv, roun­ded up five men and sum­ma­ri­ly exe­cu­t­ed one of them. A wit­ness told Human Rights Watch that sol­di­ers for­ced the five men to kne­el on the side of the road, pul­led their T-shirts over their heads, and shot one of the men in the back of the head. “He fell [over],” the wit­ness said, “and the women [pre­sent at the sce­ne] screamed.”

src: click

Das war dann nur vier Tage spä­ter der Hook einer Blin­ken Rede: click

That’s just one per­son Rus­si­an sol­di­ers kil­led in Bucha. Accord­ing to Ukraine’s pro­se­cu­tor gene­ral, they’ve alrea­dy found 410 bodies of dead civi­li­ans in that one town alo­ne. And it’s not just Bucha.

Bis­her gibt es übri­gens zwei Augen­zeu­gen des Massakers.

Hier noch eini­ge debun­king Links zu Fake News rund um Butscha, sowie zu inves­ti­ga­ti­ve Reportagen:
Busi­ness insi­der: click
bel­ling­cat: click
The insi­der: click
Human rights watch (inter­views): click

Und ein Maxar US Army con­tract über knapp 50 Mil­lio­nen USD aus dem März 2031: click

The U.S. Army Com­bat Capa­bi­li­ties Deve­lo­p­ment Com­mand C5ISR Cen­ter, Intel­li­gence & Infor­ma­ti­on War­fa­re Direc­to­ra­te awar­ded Maxar the Small Busi­ness Inno­va­ti­on Rese­arch (SBIR) Pha­se III con­tract in sup­port of Army ope­ra­ti­ons and intel­li­gence to inclu­de Com­ba­tant Com­man­ds and other government sta­ke­hol­ders. Sup­port ser­vices will inclu­de gathe­ring, ana­ly­zing and mani­pu­la­ting GEOINT and other intel­li­gence sources as the basis for pre­dic­ti­ve ana­ly­sis tools and algo­rith­ms, inclu­ding Maxar’s Signa­tu­re Ana­lyst, a pre­dic­ti­ve ana­ly­tics tool deve­lo­ped under a SBIR Pha­se I and Pha­se II program.

Pre­dic­ti­ve ana­ly­tics, voll super.

Heute ist mal wieder so ein ganz normaler Tag

08. April 2022

… an dem Anne­lie­se Roh­rer mal eben die Abschaf­fung der UNO for­dert, weil sie nicht mora­lisch genug ist.
src: click

Oder weil die Regeln im Secu­ri­ty Coun­cil nicht prä­zi­se genug sind um etwas zu bewirken.

Komisch, dass uns das nicht frü­her auf­ge­fal­len ist.….….….….….….….….….….….….

Ah, ist wohl doch nur, weil die UNO hier nicht mora­lisch genug ist.

Dan­ke, Liesl!

Chomsky is going to town..

08. April 2022

Delight­ful. For me at least. 🙂

Watch at 1.25x speed, Chom­sky beco­mes more par­se­ab­le then, in his old age.

Also two additions.

Rea­son for “but why den­azi­fi­ca­ti­on, that always ‘mis­sed’ ” for some rea­son, could be assu­med to be, that you need a pro­pa­gan­da pre­text to have peop­le, all of a sud­den shoot at their ‘bro­ther­ly neigh­bors’ - or at anyo­ne real­ly. Look up dehu­ma­niz­a­ti­on in war­fa­re in any lexi­con, really.

If I hear the “but how can rus­sia be trus­ted at all, after it vio­la­ted the peace gua­ran­tee it gave to Ukrai­ne as a basis for nuclear dis­ar­ma­ment!” stance one more time, I’ll just stand up and lea­ve the room. How could rus­sia be trus­ted tomor­row, or in a signi­fi­cant­ly wea­ke­ned sta­te, or two years from now, or as a chi­ne­se satel­li­te sta­te, or… Now draw up the likely num­bers of lives lost in each sce­n­a­rio, and com­pa­re them to your “I feel can now be trus­ted indi­ca­tor” you just made up based on your per­so­nal fee­lings about a man. But the cra­zy Putin though! Plea­se quan­ti­fy. Once that sunk in, lets agree on figu­ring this one out along the way, befo­re we only have one per­son left stan­ding in a zero sum game con­fi­gu­ra­ti­on - to the end.

I mean I under­stand how hating the new Nazis, no - I mean the new rus­si­an ones, has beco­me all chic and stuff, but come on… Turn on your logi­cal faci­li­ties at right around this point in the argu­ment, wont you?

edit: New pro­blem as of yes­ter­day: Nazis on all sides. Figh­t­ing against Nazis on all other sides. Spea­king in par­lia­ments, get­ting shun­ned for being Nazis. (via fefe) edit3: One more Nazi.

edit2: As a con­trast, you can watch Zei­han again. 🙂
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UwPMtmuuVNw

Macron sieht keinen Ausweg aus dem Krieg in Europa vor Mitte Mai

08. April 2022

Er habe „Stun­den“ in Gesprä­chen mit dem rus­si­schen Staats­chef ver­bracht. „Jede Dis­kus­si­on ist von Zynis­mus geprägt, es ist nie ein Ver­gnü­gen“, sag­te Macron, der den „Dia­log“ als sei­ne „Pflicht“ bezeichnete.

Er füg­te hin­zu, dass er nicht vor „Mit­te Mai“ einen „Aus­weg“ aus dem Krieg in Euro­pa sehe. Die Gesprä­che mit Putin sei­en aber nicht ver­ge­bens, son­dern „nütz­lich, um den Frie­den von mor­gen vorzubereiten“.

src: click
Das war übri­gens die Reak­ti­on auf das berühm­te “Wür­den sie mit Hit­ler ver­han­deln?” Zitat des Pol­ni­schen Regierungschefs.

Die EU macht der­weil schon mal Nägel mit Köp­fen und berei­tet neben dem fünf­ten Sank­ti­ons­pa­ket, das einen Import­s­top für Koh­le vor­sieht, bereits das sechs­te Sank­ti­ons­pa­ket vor, das sich gegen rus­si­sche Ölim­por­te rich­tet. Von der Ley­en spricht bereits davon, dass ein Ölem­bar­go unum­gäng­lich sei.

src: click

Die Ersatz­lie­fer­ver­trä­ge für Koh­le sei­en aber erst ein­mal kurz­fris­tig, nur weni­ge mit einer Lauf­zeit von mehr als einem Jahr.

The aftermath

08. April 2022

You’­ve heard of Bucha? You’­ve heard or see­en not­hing yet!

Situa­ti­on in Boro­dian­ka is “much sca­ri­er” than Bucha, Zelen­sky says

Ukrai­ni­an Pre­si­dent Volo­dym­yr Zelen­sky said work is under­way to clear rub­ble in the town of Boro­dian­ka and the situa­ti­on the­re is “much sca­ri­er” than that in Bucha.

Spea­king at his night­ly address on Thurs­day night, Zelen­sky said, “So far, the Rus­si­an sta­te and the Rus­si­an mili­ta­ry are the grea­test thre­at on the pla­net to free­dom, to human secu­ri­ty, to the con­cept of human rights as such. After Bucha, this is alrea­dy obvious,” he said, adding that work to clear rub­ble in Boro­dian­ka has begun. 

It’s much sca­ri­er the­re. More vic­tims of Rus­si­an inva­ders,” Zelen­sky said.
The Ukrai­ni­an pre­si­dent said simi­lar atro­ci­ties were seen in Mariu­pol as well.

What will hap­pen when the world learns the who­le truth about what the Rus­si­an mili­ta­ry did in Mariu­pol? The­re, on almost every street, is what the world saw in Bucha and other towns in the Kyiv regi­on after the with­dra­wal of Rus­si­an tro­ops. The same cru­el­ty. The same ter­ri­ble cri­mes,” he said.

Zelen­sky sug­gested that the atro­ci­ties com­mit­ted by Rus­si­an for­ces would be used as pro­pa­gan­da. CNN can­not inde­pendent­ly veri­fy the­se claims.

More and more infor­ma­ti­on is com­ing in that Rus­si­an pro­pa­gan­dists are pre­pa­ring, so to speak, a ‘mir­ror respon­se’ to the shock of all nor­mal peop­le from what they saw in Bucha. They are going to show the vic­tims in Mariu­pol as if they were not kil­led by the Rus­si­an mili­ta­ry, but by Ukrai­ni­an defen­ders of the city,” Zelen­sky said, “to do this, the occu­p­iers collect corp­ses on the streets, take them out. And can be used else­whe­re in accordance with the deve­lo­ped pro­pa­gan­da scenarios.”

Zelen­sky said every mur­der in Ukrai­ne will be inves­ti­ga­ted and every loo­ter, rapist and mur­de­rer will be found and that after what the world saw hap­pe­ning in Bucha, it is clear Rus­sia “does not obey” human rights.”

He cal­led the UN Gene­ral Assembly’s decisi­on to sus­pend Rus­sia from the Human Rights Coun­cil “fair and logi­cal” and thank­ed the coun­try that sup­por­ted the UNGA decision.

Perhaps Rus­sia will chan­ge its atti­tu­de to human rights, but at this point in time it’s not hap­pe­ning,” Zelen­sky said.

src:

Inte­res­ting paragraph:

More and more infor­ma­ti­on is com­ing in that Rus­si­an pro­pa­gan­dists are pre­pa­ring, so to speak, a “mir­ror respon­se” to the shock of all nor­mal peop­le from what they saw in Bucha. They are going to show the vic­tims in Mariu­pol as if they were kil­led not by the Rus­si­an mili­ta­ry, but by the Ukrai­ni­an defen­ders of the city. To do this, the occu­p­iers collect corp­ses on the streets, take them out and can use them else­whe­re in accordance with the ela­bo­ra­ted pro­pa­gan­da scenarios.

We are dealing with inva­ders who have not­hing human left. To jus­ti­fy their own kil­lings, they take the mur­de­red peop­le sim­ply as sce­ne­ry, as pro­pa­gan­da props. And this is a sepa­ra­te war crime, for which each of the pro­pa­gan­dists will be held accountable.

--

Ukrai­ni­an offi­cial: 26 bodies found under rub­ble of two houses in Borodianka
From CNN’s Hira Humayun

In the town of Boro­dian­ka, 26 bodies were found under the rub­ble of two houses accord­ing to Ukraine’s Pro­se­cu­tor Gene­ral Iry­na Vene­dik­to­va in a tele­vi­sed address on Thursday. 

She said the town was hit by Rus­si­an airstrikes lea­ding to a num­ber of civi­li­an casualties.

Two big houses have been dis­mant­led. Found 26 bodies. And the­se are only two houses. Atro­ci­ties are in fact a legal term that com­bi­nes three cri­mes: war cri­mes, cri­mes against huma­ni­ty and geno­ci­de. I think we need to get used to this term. This is a legal term in inter­na­tio­nal cri­mi­nal law. So Boro­dian­ka is an illus­tra­ti­ve examp­le,” she said.

src: click

Also, it was sug­gested (cant remem­ber by whom any­mo­re, but I’ve read it befo­re), that the fol­lowing was a diver­si­on attempt of the rus­si­an side - to move the news nar­ra­ti­ve off of the atrocities.

Rus­si­an offi­cial accu­ses Ukrai­ne of chan­ging deman­ds sin­ce the 2 sides met in Istanbul
From CNN’s Ulia­na Pavlo­va and Mar­tin Goillandeau

Rus­si­an For­eign Minis­ter Ser­gey Lav­rov speaks during a news con­fe­rence in Moscow on Thursday.
Rus­si­an For­eign Minis­ter Ser­gey Lav­rov speaks during a news con­fe­rence in Moscow on Thurs­day. (Alex­an­der Zemlianichenko/Pool/AP)
On Thurs­day, Rus­si­an For­eign Minis­ter Ser­gey Lav­rov accu­sed Ukrai­ni­an nego­tia­tors of chan­ging the most important pro­vi­si­ons that both sides had agreed upon during Russia-Ukraine talks in Istan­bul last month.

Lav­rov said that a draft agree­ment pre­sen­ted on Wed­nes­day by Ukrai­ni­an nego­tia­tors “show­ed a depar­tu­re from the most important pro­vi­si­ons fixed at the mee­ting in Istan­bul,” adding that the new Ukrai­ni­an draft agree­ment did not inclu­de an ear­lier pro­po­sal by Kyiv to exclu­de Cri­mea and Sebas­to­pol from the future secu­ri­ty gua­ran­tees Ukrai­ne is demanding.

Lav­rov also said Ukrai­ni­ans sug­gested that “the pro­blems of Cri­mea and Don­bas should be brought to the mee­ting of the pre­si­dents of Rus­sia and Ukrai­ne,” a pro­po­sal deemed “unac­cep­ta­ble” by Rus­sia, as Ukrai­ni­an Pre­si­dent Volo­dym­yr Zelen­sky has repeated­ly sta­ted that such a mee­ting is pos­si­ble only after the ces­sa­ti­on of hostilities.

At the next sta­ge, the Ukrai­ni­an side will cer­tain­ly ask for the with­dra­wal of tro­ops and will put for­ward new pre­con­di­ti­ons,” Lav­rov said.

Accord­ing to the Rus­si­an For­eign Minis­ter, the Ukrai­ni­an side has also chan­ged its stance on a pro­vi­si­on that Moscow could oppo­se any future mili­ta­ry maneu­vers invol­ving for­eign for­ces in Ukrai­ni­an territory.

Lav­rov said that the ina­bi­li­ty to find a nego­tia­ted agree­ment with Ukrai­ne “demons­tra­tes the true inten­ti­ons of Kyiv, its line to drag on and even make the nego­tia­ti­ons fail, rejec­ting the agree­ments that had been found.”

We see this as a mani­fes­ta­ti­on of the fact that the Kyiv regime is con­trol­led by Washing­ton and its allies, who are pushing Pre­si­dent Zelen­sky to con­ti­nue hos­ti­li­ties,” he added.
Lav­rov said the Rus­si­an dele­ga­ti­on would “con­ti­nue the nego­tia­ti­on pro­cess,” pro­mo­ting its draft agree­ment, which accord­ing to Lav­rov “clear­ly and in full, sets out all the key posi­ti­ons and demands.”

Lav­rov did not reve­al the details of that draft agreement.

src: click
Regard­less, in its­elf thats worth to be acknowledged.